I would like to start with an observation regarding the upper left part of the photo. It definitely works well and goes perfectly with the lower part of the left side, or the low, left quarter if you will, because the combination of the lines, the parallelism and the symmetrical quality create the feeling of order; serenity and organization of the image depicted. Yet, the right half is an obvious conceptual contrast to the left part in the sense that it alludes to and suggests instability; chaos, disorder and conveys a feeling of unease, something horrible lurking which is a brilliant clash of the two realities.
Since it strives to convey the notions of loss and sorrow following the horrible tragedy in Japan, I believe that this picture renders exactly that: the urge to bring order into disorder, to restore peace and organization.
Personally, I am disgusted by the flood of cheap contributions to deviant art, but at the same time it makes me happy, because the influx of all sorts of creations carries along something remarkable as this, and I praise your vision and your work.
However, I suggest you increase the contrast in terms of shades of grey (no pun intended), to create a stronger and more powerful feel to it.
nice pic here! technically speaking theres a lot of good stuff going on here. the first thing i notice is the excellently strong lines, both vertical and horizontal. nice when you can employ the different lines in an image. the detail is really nice and the image has come out pretty sharp.
the next obvious thing worth mentioning here is the use of black and white. i myself am a fan of bw images, when you take color out of the equation the composition, subject, and tone become so very important.
i'm not sure if i am using this phrase right, but theres some negative space in the upper left of the image. if there had been some clouds, or birds to fill that space i think it would have topped off an already great shot. that would be the only thing that stands out to me as something to improve this nice shot.
C'est risqué parait il de couper une photo par un horizon en son milieu, mais là, tout fonctionne, le format carré, les lignes au sol parallèles au lignes des nuages, c'est très beau... J'aime beaucoup l'idée de ces bateaux échoués...
Bah, quand il s'agit d'un carré, on peut le faire. Le carré permet de jouer sur la symétrie plus que sur le tiers. Là, en l'occurence, tu as un objet situé au tiers sur la ligne horizontal à gauche (le ponton en pierre) et tout le reste qui est organisé en demi ou en quart avec des lignes de force qui pointent en perspective sur un quart à gauche toujours sur la ligne d'horizon bien sûr). Je le dis parce que je l'analyse maintenant, mais au moment où j'ai fait la photo, je n'y ai pas pensé. J'évite d'y penser d'ailleur, parce que je trouve que l'effet est toujours meilleur quand on y va "naïvement". Merci l'ami
Entièrement d'accord, et pis oui les lignes sont magnifiquement placées, le chemin de l'oeil est top sur ton cliché... De rien en tout cas et merci encore pour ce temps pris à répondre Tu es doué, ça c'est clair, net et précis!!! Bravo encore...
Yet, the right half is an obvious conceptual contrast to the left part in the sense that it alludes to and suggests instability; chaos, disorder and conveys a feeling of unease, something horrible lurking which is a brilliant clash of the two realities.
Since it strives to convey the notions of loss and sorrow following the horrible tragedy in Japan, I believe that this picture renders exactly that: the urge to bring order into disorder, to restore peace and organization.
Personally, I am disgusted by the flood of cheap contributions to deviant art, but at the same time it makes me happy, because the influx of all sorts of creations carries along something remarkable as this, and I praise your vision and your work.
However, I suggest you increase the contrast in terms of shades of grey (no pun intended), to create a stronger and more powerful feel to it.
the next obvious thing worth mentioning here is the use of black and white. i myself am a fan of bw images, when you take color out of the equation the composition, subject, and tone become so very important.
i'm not sure if i am using this phrase right, but theres some negative space in the upper left of the image. if there had been some clouds, or birds to fill that space i think it would have topped off an already great shot. that would be the only thing that stands out to me as something to improve this nice shot.
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.